The 8 Best Whole-House Water Filters for Rust: Reviewed and Compared (2024)

Updated on:
January 8, 2024

Rust is a pesky problem that plagues not only well owners but also those relying on city water. It’s caused by either high iron concentration in groundwater or corroding pipes.

The obvious solution is to install a high functioning whole-house filter that gets rid of the dreaded orange colored water. However, with every brand shouting out its grand claims, it becomes quite a challenge to weed out the fakes from the real ones. 

So, after extensive research, thorough reviews, and rigorous testing, I’ve got you covered with my top picks for the best whole-house water filter for rust.

1. SpringWell CWH-1 Whole-House Cartridge System: 9.70/10 

  • Best filtration and durability 
  • $646.51

I highly recommend the Springwell CWH-1 because it does an amazing job of getting rid of rust, sulfur, and chlorine. Its consistent performance and longevity set it apart, making it a worthy option.

Pros

Usually, when we talk about rust, we’re concerned about iron content, the main culprit. However, it’s important to note that iron is not the only contaminant present in your tap water. So you need a water filter like the SpringWell CWH-1 that targets multiple contaminants like rust, clay, soil, sulfur, chlorine, chloramine, PFOA, pesticides, and foul taste and odor.

The SpringWell CWH-1 is a two-stage filter consisting of a sediment pre-filter and a carbon cartridge filter. The 5-micron sediment filter is the first defense against pesky iron flakes. It’s effective enough to be used as a standalone system if your rust problem isn’t severe. 

The next stage has SpringWell’s patented carbon-filter cartridge, which is the main deal. My test showed consistent performance during the complete life cycle, which is surprising because most filters start to clog once they cross half of their filtration capacity. 

Technically, SpringWell’s two-stage whole-house filtration is supposed to be subpar compared with Express Water’s three-stage filtration, but I didn’t notice any difference in performance. In comparison, it’s more convenient because you need one fewer cartridge change.

Another competitive advantage SpringWell CWH-1 has is its phenomenal 20 GPM flow rate, which is the highest among all the available options. Even at low water pressures, you won’t feel a difference. 

Installation was quite easy. It takes less space, and the ergonomic design makes it easy to replace the filters. 

The sediment filter needs a change every six months, while the carbon filter can last up to twelve months. All the components and filter cartridges are NSF certified.

The SpringWell CWH-1 costs $646.51, and the replacements are priced at $128 annually. All products have a lifetime warranty, though it comes with certain conditions that you can read here

If you face severe iron contamination in your well water, install the SpringWell whole-house iron filter — it’s well equipped to handle extreme cases.

Cons

The SpringWell CWH-1 is expensive compared to water filters of similar specifications. The filter quality is top-notch, and the flow rate is amazing. The brand also offers an easy installment plan on all of its products and a six-month money-back guarantee that makes up for the high price. 

Overall

The SpringWell CWH-1 is a reliable option for households with rust contamination. The whole-house filter effectively targets sediment, chlorine, and sulfur, making it a comprehensive filtration solution. The compact design makes it easier to install and carry with you if you ever plan to move out. 

Want to get rid of rust in your tap water for good? Buy the SpringWell CWH-1 today

2. Express Water Whole House System: 8.70/10 

  • Good filtration but needs frequent filter replacement
  • $499.99

Express Water’s whole-house system offers great protection against rust, dust, scale, manganese, chlorine taste, and smell. The filter comes with pressure gauges that let you examine the flow in real time. 

Pros

Express Water makes effective filters for specific contaminants like iron and manganese. The filter design is typical, with three filter cartridges, each with a specific purpose.

First, a 5-micron sediment filter removes the sediment and other organic nasties from the water. Its transparent casing makes it easier to know when it needs a filter change. Sediment filters usually require change much earlier than the rest of the cartridges. 

Next is the iron and manganese filter, which removes rust particles. The filter did its job perfectly, and my test samples were crystal clear. Lastly, there is an activated-carbon filter that does a decent job of removing chlorine and chloramine from water. 

The Express Water whole-house water filter system comes with a stand that you can either mount on the wall or place as it is on the floor. The pressure-release button and a simple twist-off filter casing make replacement super easy. However, connecting it to the main water supply is a bit of a hassle. More about that later. 

The pressure gauges are a nice addition because they let you monitor the flow rate of each cartridge. Once the flow rate diminishes, you can safely assume it needs a filter change.

Despite three-stage filtration, the flow rate remains consistently high, around 15 GPM. It’s NSF certified, which means quality is top-notch.

The ExpressWater whole-house filter is budget friendly and costs $499.99. The annual maintenance cost is $169.99, and you get a one-year warranty on all products. 

Cons

The brand recommends changing its filter after three to six months. However, heavy rust contamination may cause the filter to fail after just two months. The frequent filter change is inconvenient and adds to the total cost. 

But what really pushed my buttons were the sloppy connectors that leaked frequently. I had to use tons of Teflon tape to secure the pipes.

Overall

The Express Water whole-house water filter is a worthy second option because of its highly effective iron and manganese filtration. The flow rate is pretty consistent, and pressure gauges help monitor performance

3. Waterdrop Whole House Filter: 7.5/10 

  • Effective cleaning but a hassle to install
  • $179.99

The Waterdrop WHF21-FG is a compact whole-house filter that fits easily in a tight space and efficiently removes harmful rust and manganese particles from the water supply. 

Pros

Waterdrop filters are durable, with compact designs that are really ergonomic. 

Waterdrop claims it to be a five-stage filtration process, that is, if you count the individual layers of the filter media, but that’s rather an exaggeration. It’s two stages at best. Nonetheless, the filtration is good, and my test showed a significant decrease in rust. 

This WHF21-FG dual cartridge consists of a GAC (granular-activated carbon) filter and an iron and manganese filter that really packs a punch. It’s good for removing sediment, chlorine, taste, odor, iron, and manganese from the water supply.

Both filters are rated 5 microns and maintain a flow rate of 15 GPM, and I experienced no clogging during prolonged use.

You can expect a single cartridge to last six months. However, heavy contamination reduces the lifespan to three months. Replacing the filter is easy, thanks to pressure-relief buttons. 

The products are certified by SGS against NSF standards. So, the quality is on par with SpringWell and Express Water. 

Waterdrop’s whole-house filter is a budget-friendly option at $179.99, with the annual maintenance cost running around a reasonable $29.99. 

Cons

I really struggled while connecting the pipes with the brass connectors. No matter how many threads or how much Teflon tape I used, the leakage persisted. The only solution I found to be effective (thanks to an online review) was to use a plastic adapter and connect them with the brass ones of the filter. It works for now, but the brand needs to address this issue. 

Waterdrop doesn’t offer any warranty on the product. You’ll get a 30-day money-back guarantee, but once the refund window has passed, you’re on your own. 

Overall

The Waterdrop whole-house filtration system is a compact, effective, and durable product for removing rust from tap water. Its effectiveness makes it a worthy third option, but if you want a hassle-free installation, then my choice is SpringWell CWH-1. 

4. iSpring Whole House Filter

iSpring is a well-known brand, and its product line is fantastic. The WGB32BM model works well against rust, manganese, chlorine, sediment, and herbicide. All filters are rated 5 microns and trap contaminants effectively.

The three-stage filtration comprises iron, carbon, and sediment filters, each with a lifespan of six months. The iron and sediment filter may spoil much earlier if you have severe rust contamination. So, expect a filter change every 1.5 to 2 months. 

The unit itself is quite heavy compared to Express Water, which is also a three-stage filter system. However, the installation is a breeze, and the connectors don’t leak. 

In the first few months, you can expect a strong flow rate of 15 GPM, but once the gunk starts building up, the speed takes a serious hit.

Use a pre-filter with an iSpring whole-house filter to enhance performance. However, it comes at an extra cost. I really like the build quality, and as expected, it’s NSF certified. 

The iSpring 3-stage whole-house filter is priced at $473.68; by my estimation, the annual maintenance cost is $194.97. The brand also offers a one-year limited warranty on this product. Although the starting price seems reasonable, the maintenance cost will really hit your budget hard.

5. Home Master Water Filtration System

Home Master’s whole-house water filter gives the best performance when it comes to removing sediment, rust, manganese, chlorine, bacteria, and other organic compounds. But the reason it’s further down the list is its difficult maintenance. 

It has three filter cartridges, namely sediment, GAC, and iron filter, each with a unique makeup. Normally, filters have a single micron rating, but these have multiple micron ratings. The outer layers start at 25 microns and gradually decrease all the way down to one micron at the core, making it extremely effective. 

Home Master water filters are big, comparable to SpringWell in size (less restriction), and that’s why they maintain a high flow rate of 15 GPM even at one micron nominal rating. However, the huge size also makes it harder to install and may require a plumber’s assistance. 

The filters last for six to twelve months depending upon use. It also treats iron bacteria and sulfur odor (rotten egg smell) and taste, but that significantly reduces the filter’s effective life. 

Home Master’s whole-house filter is made from sturdy food-grade material, but I didn’t find any certification, which is a red flag.

It’s priced at $503, and the brand offers a two-year warranty. However, the real issue is the expensive filter cartridges, which cost $245.05! In the best-case scenario, they only last for eight months, and then you have to splurge again on the replacements. 

You can find better alternatives, like SpringWell CWH-1, at a much cheaper cost that deliver the same quality performance. 

6. Aqua-Pure Whole House Water Filter

A popular American conglomerate, 3M, owns the Aqua-Pure brand. The filters are high quality and intelligently designed to have multiple-stage filtration in a single cartridge. The Aqua-Pure AP903 uses carbon-block technology to remove well and municipal water contaminants. 

I also found a significant decrease in rust particles during my test. The filter is quite easy to install since there’s only one cartridge, but what’s more convenient is its Sanitary Quick Change (SQC) design that lets you change the cartridge within a minute.

Other than the SpringWell WCH-1, it’s the only filter with a 20 GPM flow rate on my list. The product is also certified by NSF and WQA.

This Aqua-Pure filter is rated for 5 microns and has a large filtration capacity of 100,000 gallons, lasting one year easily. However, the replacements are not readily available, which can seriously disrupt your water supply. That’s why I ranked it lower.

It costs $347.66, and the replacement cartridge is priced at $290, which is the highest on my list.

No doubt you see a pattern beginning here. Some products have a lower starting price, but their maintenance cost is extremely high. So make sure you buy the right product that will give you good performance and is economical in the long run.

7. Culligan Whole House Heavy Duty Filtration System

The Culligan WH-HD200-C works well against sediment, especially rust particles. 

It’s a single-stage filter with a five-micron sediment filter and sturdy housing. This filter is not like your high-end whole-house water filter with multiple stages, but it’s good for a specific purpose, in this case sediment concentration. 

There is a 25-micron-rated sediment filter that does an okay job of removing the contaminants. But what really bothered me is its extremely low flow rate of 3 GPM. I get it, the filtration is thorough, but this doesn’t mean the flow rate has to be so low. 

Culligan sediment filters last six months, and the housing comes with a bypass valve, making it convenient to replace old filters. 

The quality is good, and all the components are NSF certified. It costs $73.52, and replacements are priced at $23.79 annually. There is no warranty on this product. 

If you’re looking to target rust contamination only, go ahead and install this single-stage filter. However, if you also want to tackle concerns like chlorine, manganese, VOCs, bacteria, and other organic contaminants as well, I recommend going with one of my top two recommendations.

8. PUREPLUS Whole House Water Filter

The Pureplus filter features an uncannily similar design to the Express Water whole-house water filter. I don’t know which brand originally came up with the design, but Pureplus’ lack of certification raises concern and doesn’t build a strong case in its favor.

It’s a three-stage filter system with typical GAC, iron, and sediment filters and a 5-micron rating. The filtration is meh compared with top-performing filters like Home Master and iSpring, which are priced similarly. 

Depending on the water pressure, Pureplus can deliver a flow rate between 9 and 15 GPM. The installation is easy. It comes with a steel stand, which can be placed indoors or outdoors. 

This whole-house filter costs $499.99, and replacements are $96.68. However, it is disappointing that Pureplus doesn’t offer any warranty on this product, which is something I expected, especially considering its price.

The Bottom Line

When it comes to tackling the challenging issue of rust and multiple contaminants, one filter stands out as the ultimate champion — the SpringWell CWH-1 whole-house filter. It targets rust and puts up a strong defense against various other contaminants.

Don’t let its two-stage filtration fool you — it delivers results comparable to the three-stage filtration of ExpressWater and iSpring. SpringWell’s CWH-1 filter design is well thought out, making it a leakage-free system. I was amazed by the 20 GPM flow rate, one of the highest in the market.

The six-month filter life is reasonably good, and it doesn’t clog near the end of its life cycle like many others. The product quality is excellent, and all of its components are NSF certified. SpringWell also offers a lifetime guarantee on its products, which makes up for its slightly high price tag. 

The SpringWell CWH-1 whole-house system is a way to go if you want a rust-free water supply in your home without frequent maintenance.

Research Methodology

A lot goes into reviewing and ranking any filtration system. You can’t phone it in because it directly relates to people’s health. So here is a sneak peek into the research methodology that helped me find the best whole-house water filters for rust. 

Step 1: A list of whole-house water filters for rust

I started out by finding the best water filters that targeted rust and related contaminants. Rust falls under the category of “sediment,” so naturally, sediment filters are effective against rust. Also, I included products that had specialized iron and manganese filters. 

I visited local markets and online stores, and after two days of drudge work, I finally managed to list eight whole-house filtration systems designed to remove rust. 

Step 2: Product analysis

Next, I needed to set parameters and criteria for reviewing whole-house filters to keep things manageable. After going through the guidelines of the EPA and CDC, I made a list of the following criteria for product analysis: 

  • Filter type
  • Targeted contaminants 
  • Product certification 
  • Filter life 
  • Flow rates
  • Installation 
  • Maintenance
  • Warranty 
  • Overall cost 

I only reviewed the whole-house filters that are effective against rust particles in both well and municipal water. I’ve done a separate review of iron filters targeting high iron concentration, specifically in well water. 

Step 3: Online reviews 

Even though I had all the specifications and related data, I still lacked insights regarding real-life performance. To fill this gap, I examined hundreds of verified online customer reviews on reputable platforms such as Amazon, Google, Home Depot, and Consumer Reports.

Step 4: Interviews with real customers

In pursuit of higher sales, brands often sponsor fake reviews, which often lead to bad purchases. To keep things as authentic as possible, I interviewed real-life customers in my surrounding area. 

I live in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, where rust-colored tap water is common. Using social media, I managed to find willing customers who had a whole-house water filtration system installed in their houses. 

Some folks griped about those darn leaky fittings, while others were downright frustrated with the constant clogging issues. Can you believe it? There were even some products that had fancy online branding, but when it came to performance, they were just disappointing. I made sure to take note of all this valuable insight.

Step 5: Interviews with brands 

To keep things fair and square, I reached out to the brands and asked about the issues people were complaining about.

You know what? Some brands were using the NSF mark on their products, but when I checked online, they weren’t officially listed. But there were a few brands that were super helpful and responsive, and I bumped up their rankings for their top-notch customer service.

On the flip side, some brands didn’t even bother to reply. I took all of this into account when finalizing the rankings.

Step 6: Test drives

The most thrilling part of my research was actually getting my hands dirty and testing those whole-house water filtration systems myself. Most filters had a 100,000-gallon capacity, so I ran each for a quarter of that and examined the flow rate and filter media. I collected water samples at intervals to test for rust and other contaminants.

I also noticed some filters had fragile brass connectors that leaked. This influenced my ranking. The whole process took six tiring weeks, but it was worth it. I recycled all the filtered water to stay eco-friendly.

Step 7: Ratings

Now that I had all the juicy data, it was time to crunch those numbers and get down to business. I whipped out my trusty spreadsheet and arranged everything in there. Armed with my scoring system, I carefully evaluated each filter and ranked them based on the following criteria. 

  • My testing
  • Customer experience 
  • Product specifications
  • Ease of installation
  • Certification 
  • Overall cost 
  • Warranty 

It was a crucial step to separate the top dogs from the rest of the pack and make the ultimate decision. 

Final Thoughts

The SpringWell CWH-01 whole-house filter is the top scorer in my research. It was a tough competition between my top five recommendations, but in the end, SpringWell stood out for these features:

  • Heavy duty filtration
  • High flow rate 
  • Premium quality 
  • Long filter life
  • No leakages
  • Lifetime warranty 

Sure, the initial cost may be a tad higher compared to others, but let me tell you, the filtration quality and durability of the SpringWell are in a league of their own. 

If you’re ready to kick rust out of your drinking water, get your hands on the SpringWell CWH-10 right here, right now.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments